Issue No. 918

Published 28 Jan

Recognition in the Age of Tempest

Published on 28 Jan 20:52 min

Recognition in the Age of Tempest


One month has passed since Israel became the first UN member state to formally recognise Somaliland's sovereignty, a decision that has placed Hargeisa at the centre of a significant geopolitical storm. Despite the initial euphoria in Somaliland, the anticipated cascade of diplomatic recognition from other countries has yet to materialise. Yet, hope still abounds and officials in Somaliland are busy plotting their next move.

President Abdirahman Irro was in Davos, Switzerland, last week to attend the World Economic Forum, as part of a strategic public relations effort orchestrated by the UAE ports operator DP World. The aim was to highlight Somaliland's stability and democratic credentials to the global elite. President Irro met with high-level individuals, including business tycoon Eric Trump, presenting the case for recognition as a business proposition: a stable, democratic state controlling a vital maritime chokepoint, rich in natural resources, and home to the modern port of Berbera. However, recent statements have clarified that although brief pleasantries were exchanged between the two, no private meeting or substantive discussion took place.

The move by Israel triggered diplomatic fallout with Somalia, with the Federal Government of Somalia (FGS) intentionally conflating its mounting domestic political and security crises with the new external threat – a classic "diversionary conflict" – to boost national support. Attempts by Mogadishu to inflame emotions and ignite a popular uprising against the recognition backfired badly. Reactions in Jubaland and Puntland appear to have been decidedly muted.  In a speech which arguably captures the dominant view in the south beyond the Mogadishu bubble, Jubaland President Ahmed Madoobe accused the Hassan Sheikh administration of contributing significantly to the crisis of “Somaliland’s estrangement” and the sense of alienation that compelled Hargeisa to “seek recognition from and embrace Israel”.

The events of the past month have shown the pitfalls - if not the folly - of geopolitical ‘catastrophising.’ First, the wild claims that Somalia would immediately collapse and the Horn would implode if Somaliland were recognised have been wide of the mark. This apocalyptic vision, pushed zealously by Villa Somalia, was always dubious, a red herring to scare the internationals and deter a realistic assessment of Somaliland and why it merits greater international recognition. 

Somaliland’s recognition is coming at a fraught moment, and understanding the wider global picture is essential. In Davos, leaders bemoaned the collapse of the rule-based world order. Canada’s Mark Carney was even more forthright in a speech to the delegates: “Let me be direct. We are in the midst of a rupture, not a transition.” The Canadian leader is partially correct in his assessment. In the Horn, some analysts have latched onto the Somaliland recognition to amplify the vision of a world unravelling – a form of geopolitical conflation. 

There is little doubt that the world has entered its most precarious geopolitical era since 1945. Intense competition has started among emerging powers seeking to establish new spheres of influence, and a record escalation in lethal armed conflicts. This global upheaval is driven by a fierce scramble for natural resources, access to external markets, and control over chokepoints, strategic maritime trade corridors and waterways. As the United States appears to retreat from traditional theatres and the alliance structures that once maintained the Pax Americana, a volatile vacuum has emerged, fueling a chaotic race by major powers to redefine the international order.

Today's geopolitical turmoil must be examined alongside other significant shifts and megatrends: the merging of various conflict systems across large areas, the breakdown of the post-war multilateral system, the rise of transaction-based foreign policy, and the growth of youth-driven mass uprisings. These issues are exacerbated by intensifying climate change stresses, economic difficulties, worsening state fragility, and general political instability. 

​It is prudent to caution against ‘catastrophising’ the current flux. Geopolitical upheavals are often cyclical rather than linear, driven by recurring patterns of generational shifts, power transfers, and socio-economic dynamics. Undeniably, the world is currently traversing a critical ‘crisis’ phase of these long-term cycles. This period of disruption, while marking the unravelling of the post-Cold War order, is also a period of adaptation and the formation of new balances of power. The perceived chaos may in fact be a transition phase towards a "new muddled order", where states are actively forging new bilateral and regional agreements and building resilience to current shocks, rather than facing an inevitable collapse into global disorder.

The fallout between Saudi Arabia and the UAE is serious and playing directly into the Somaliland recognition crisis. It could inflame tensions and drive proxy conflicts. Gulf alliances are generally tenuous, and there is no strong evidence yet to suggest that the rift between the two former allies is not amenable. In fact, history and precedent suggest that the Saudis and the Emiratis would eventually prefer reconciliation to a protracted feud, which saps their collective strength. The two may work out ways to deconflict their interests in Somalia, Somaliland and Yemen. Mogadishu’s bet on enlisting the Saudis in its war against Somaliland and Israel is unlikely to succeed.​

There are many trigger points for armed conflict and wider instability. Arguably, the gravest risk may be the escalating tensions between Turkiye and Israel, not all of which is driven by Somaliland and the recognition issue. The two powers are increasingly at odds over many issues, and strategists on both sides contend that the danger of a possible future conflict is mounting.

Israel is a Red Sea littoral state historically more interested in states closer to home – Egypt, Sudan and Eritrea. Sudan’s Red Sea coast was the staging post of an Israeli operation in the 1980s  and early 1990s  to smuggle thousands of Falasha Ethiopian Jews to Israel. In Eritrea, Israel maintained an electronic signals intercept station in one of the Dahlak Islands. The foray into Somaliland extends Israel’s range down the vital sea lane and brings it into close proximity with Turkiye  – the pre-eminent external player in Somalia. Israel’s primary strategic interest is to capitalise on its new Somaliland foothold to degrade the Houthis in Yemen and to counter Iran. 

Tel Aviv and Ankara are astute regional players, with historically strong diplomatic relations and the capacity to engage to deconflict their volatile Somalia/Somalia stakes. The two are already doing that in Syria. International actors with leverage and good ties to these two formidable adversaries must step in to de-escalate.

The Somali Wire Team

To continue reading, create a free account or log in.

Gain unlimited access to all our Editorials. Unlock Full Access to Our Expert Editorials — Trusted Insights, Unlimited Reading.

Create your Sahan account Login

Unlock lifetime access to all our Premium editorial content

You may also be interested in

Issue No. 924
From Ankara to Cairo to Doha: Villa Somalia courts the 'region'
The Somali Wire

Somali President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's diplomatic tour continues apace. Since 26 December and Israel's bombshell recognition of Somaliland, Hassan Sheikh has travelled to Türkiye, Ethiopia, and, in recent days, Egypt and Qatar, rallying support for his government, and Somalia's "unity, sovereignty, and territorial integrity." And he has found success in three of these four, with Ankara, Cairo, and Doha sitting on one side of a broader Red Sea schism against the Emirati-Israeli axis. Somaliland ally, Emirati broker and regionally isolated Ethiopia, as ever, continues to hedge its bets


19:07 min read 11 Feb
Issue No. 318
Ethiopia and Eritrea's Endless Struggle
The Ethiopian Cable

There are rivalries born from distance, and rivalries born from closeness. Nearly three decades of Ethiopia-Eritrea feuding —barring the brief, destructive interregnum in Tigray —is borne of the latter. The depth of the socio-cultural linkages between modern-day Ethiopia and Eritrea dates back centuries, with the shared highlands part of the sophisticated Axumite kingdom that stretched into the Arabian Peninsula.


17:58 min read 10 Feb
Issue No. 923
Police in the Chamber
The Somali Wire

Police officers restraining lawmakers in a parliamentary chamber is rarely a healthy sign of a functioning democracy. With just a couple of months left before the Somali president's term expires, his allies in parliament are plumbing fresh depths to cement the latest centralising revisions to the Provisional Constitution. And in the past week alone, dozens more opposition MPs have been summarily thrown out after resisting such unilateral amendments in scenes reminiscent of a 20th-century putsch, rather than a putative parliamentary democracy. Plans to declare a parallel parliament are now underway.


18:30 min read 09 Feb
Issue No. 922
Two bloody days in Baidoa
The Somali Wire

A tentative calm has returned to the South West city of Baidoa. On Wednesday afternoon, heavy fighting broke out in the town's western neighbourhoods, and after two days of bloody clashes, dozens appear to be injured or killed. What began as a land dispute near Baidoa's livestock market quickly degenerated, pulling in forces aligned with a federal minister as intense gunfire and mortars rocked the city. This was no small matter —and despite assertions that it was a case of disarming rogue forces, it was anything but, and instead appears to be the latest product of ratcheting electoral tensions. With South West President Abdiaziz Laftagareen today announcing the expulsion of the government's most senior electoral official from Baidoa, is this the final straw for the fractious Baidoa-Mogadishu relationship?


16:32 min read 06 Feb
Issue No. 115
In Juba, Even the Dead Get Appointed
The Horn Edition

Dead men do not just walk in Juba — they can now be appointed to election task forces. In one of the most bizarre stories in recent memory, Salva Kiir's government selected Steward Sorobo Budia last week for a new task force comprised of signatories to South Sudan's long-collapsed 2018 peace agreement. Three days later, the president's office was forced to admit that Hon. Sorobo—a former politician from a negligible party —had died 6 years prior, making him unable to serve on the farcical "Leadership Body of the Parties Signatory to the R-ARCSS for Dialogue on Election-Related Matters."


7:03 min read 05 Feb
Issue No. 921
Operation Ottoman
The Somali Wire

Yesterday morning, Mogadishu residents were woken by a noise unlike the usual dawn bustle of bajaj taxis — F-16 Viper fighter jets sweeping over the city. Beyond the shock and awe of the newest batch of Turkish military hardware in the Somali capital, it was the latest potent symbol of the centre stage Somalia has taken within Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan's grand neo-Ottoman vision. As if in a military parade, Turkish drones, jets, helicopters, and warships have all made appearances in Somalia in recent weeks, displaying some of Türkiye's latest homegrown tech —as well as the F-16s licensed from Lockheed Martin. And so, the steady militarisation of bilateral relations—and Ankara's penetration of Somalia's security sector—continues apace.


20:42 min read 04 Feb
Issue No. 317
Tigray edges closer to war-- again
The Ethiopian Cable

A brief resumption of fighting in Western Tigray between Tigrayan and federal troops last week has returned the fraught context of northern Ethiopia back to the precipice of full-blown conflict. Details remain murky, but for at least three days, deadly clashes flared in the contested Tselemt area between Tigrayan troops and the Ethiopian military.


24:22 min read 03 Feb
Issue No. 920
Villa Somalia Grounds Hopes of Dialogue
The Somali Wire

Last week, the brief glimmer towards a path to resolving Somalia's turgid political impasse was extinguished almost as soon as it emerged. The Council for the Future of Somalia (CFS) was supposedly heading to Mogadishu, including Puntland President Said Abdullahi Deni and his Jubaland counterpart Ahmed Madoobe, for talks with Villa Somalia, though their scope remained murky, and optimism that the government would be willing to consider compromise remained dim. But even these initial talks —and the first face-to-face meeting between Deni, Madoobe, and President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud in Mogadishu for well over two years —were doomed from the off.


19:03 min read 02 Feb
Issue No. 919
Unpacking Somaliland's Independence Quest
The Somali Wire

The scramble for Africa left deep scars across the continent, but few colonial partitions proved as consequential as the division of Somali territories in the late 19th century. Today, as Somaliland seeks international recognition, the story of its brief independence and hasty union with Somalia reveals how the colonial powers, keen to divest themselves of imperial responsibilities, left behind a crisis of contested sovereignty that would take decades to resolve.


14:58 min read 30 Jan
Scroll