Issue No. 208

Published 03 Oct 2023

The Dissolution of ICHREE

Published on 03 Oct 2023 17:46 min

The Dissolution of ICHREE

Tomorrow, 4 October, the United Nations International Commission of Human Rights Experts on Ethiopia (ICHREE) will be disbanded, and with its dissolution, serious international scrutiny of the Tigray War could be over. While the Commission was far from perfect, it promised to be the most significant independent and international investigation into the war’s numerous human rights violations.

The dissolution, only to be allayed by an unlikely last-minute intervention, comes despite the Commissioners’ warning on 18 September that their work was incomplete, with human rights violations ongoing in northern and western Tigray, as well as the Oromo and Amhara regions. Realpolitik and seeming indifference of the international community appear to have won out.

One of the 11 principles underpinning the November 2022 Pretoria agreement between the Federal Government of Ethiopia (FGE) and Tigrayan authorities was “accountability and justice,” in line with Ethiopia’s 1995 Constitution and the African Union’s Transitional Justice Policy Framework. The agreement further stipulated that the FGE should implement a comprehensive transitional justice mechanism developed with all stakeholders.

From the start, Addis refused to cooperate with the ICHREE, insisting that a domestic investigation and transitional justice mechanism would better serve the country. The motive behind Ethiopia’s insistence on a national transitional justice approach and a ‘comprehensive’ process is not hard to decrypt. State media reported as early as July 2022 a “discussion on transitional justice options” by an Inter-Ministerial Task Force, accountable to the Attorney General, to examine human rights violations in northern Ethiopia. The task force was seemingly established with the primary objective of creating a false equivalence between the violations of Tigrayan and federal and allied forces. Its first notable output was a press conference insinuating that ICHREE was both agenda-driven and inadequate.

If fully implemented, a comprehensive transitional justice process could still go some way to help Ethiopia make peace with itself-- with adequate self-reflection, recognition of wrongdoing, and a strong precedent of accountability. Ethiopia’s ongoing design of the transitional justice policy framework, however, leaves much to be desired.

It is the Attorney General himself who heads the Working Group on National Transitional Justice Policy. As the now obsolete Inter-Ministerial Task Force was also accountable to the AG, it was no surprise when the Ministry of Foreign Affairs announced that the post-war transitional justice process would continue investigations conducted by the task force during the war.

The Ethiopian Human Rights Commission (EHRC) conducted public consultations with UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (UN-OHCHR) regarding transitional justice at the same time the task force was discussing its agenda. According to its 8-page summary of public consultations, participants stated that “they live in constant fear of conflict and recurrence of the violations they experienced.” They needed “restitution, compensation, rehabilitation, and guarantees of non-repetition,” including “returning to their homes, living without fear, and getting their livelihoods back.” Yet while they were “ready to forgive and reconcile if there is truth and acknowledgement... including from the highest level,” they expressed “discomfort with purely state-led processes and institutions.”

The EHRC-UNOHCHR consultations were carried out before the Pretoria agreement and without Tigrayan input, but they still help to capture the needs of those in Tigray. Roughly one million Tigrayans are currently living in under-funded and over-crowded camps, having been forcibly displaced from their homes. About a third of the Tigray region is still under occupation by Eritrean and Amhara forces, 11 months on from the Pretoria agreement, with human rights violations still being committed. Thousands have starved to death since the conclusion of the war; malnutrition and hunger are spiralling as the suspension of international food aid drags on. Forget restitution or compensation. And the state-owned Commercial Bank of Ethiopia hasn’t resumed payment for pensioners. Few Tigrayans would take a state-led transitional justice mechanism seriously, and Tigrayan authorities have yet had no representation in the process.

On 22 September, in a letter to the federal Ministry of Justice, Tigray Interim Administration (TIA) Deputy Tsadkan Gebretinsae accused the current justice initiative of ignoring the Pretoria agreement, failing to consult Tigray, and being the wrong “modality.” The TIA instead proposed that an independent body should develop a comprehensive justice mechanism or that a hybrid model should be developed through collaboration among international, federal, and regional bodies.

Regardless of Tigray’s opposition, the federal government’s National Transitional Justice Working Group appears to be in its final stages, with the draft policy expected to be submitted in the coming weeks. What issues this transitional justice process might address and what it could possibly achieve are yet to be seen.

There are other immediate problems facing the domestic transitional justice mechanism. First, there is the inability of a domestic court to prosecute Eritrean soldiers responsible for grave human rights violations, such as the massacres in Axum and Adigrat in November and December 2020. Second, ongoing violence across the country, including full-blown insurgencies in Oromia and Amhara, would likely compromise the independence of federal human rights investigations, in that the Oromo Liberation Army (OLA) and Fano militia were both parties in the Tigray War.

The closure of ICHREE sends a signal to all current and future efforts at transitional justice, not just in the Horn of Africa, but around the world. The silence of the international community and the African Union, which shuttered its own investigation without fanfare in May 2023, is damning. There can not be a peaceful political transition or genuine transitional justice post-conflict without the resettlement of the victims of the war, the withdrawal of all occupying forces, restoration of livelihoods, and effective engagement with all relevant stakeholders. If the peak of transitional justice was South Africa’s experiment, let’s not allow Tigray to become its nadir.

By the Ethiopian Cable team

To continue reading, create a free account or log in.

Gain unlimited access to all our Editorials. Unlock Full Access to Our Expert Editorials — Trusted Insights, Unlimited Reading.

Create your Sahan account Login

Unlock lifetime access to all our Premium editorial content

You may also be interested in

Issue No. 985
The Hiiraan Insurrection – A Crisis Foretold
The Somali Wire

Months of simmering tensions in the Hiiraan region and escalating political rifts with Mogadishu have morphed into a full-blown armed insurrection this week. This development compounds the widening revolt across Somalia's periphery against President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's (HSM) administration, deepening its political isolation.


28:17 min read 18 Nov
Issue No. 983
Hassan Sheikh Runs Out of Road
The Somali Wire

In a landmark ruling last week, five senior judges of Somalia’s Supreme Court declared incumbent President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud’s (HSM) May 2026 term extension unlawful and held that Parliament’s mandate had expired in April 2026, thereby rendering Villa Somalia’s "one-person, one-vote" (OPOV) electoral process illegal and its outcome invalid. Consequently, the judges directed all Somali political parties to agree on a new electoral framework within 30 days and conduct a credible poll within 90 days.


25:51 min read 11 Nov
Issue No. 982
Loo Joojin Maayo – Somalia’s Runaway Train
The Somali Wire

Every political system generates its own distinctive catchphrases, slogans, and metaphors, and Somalia is no exception. Indeed, the administration of President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud (HSM) has proven to be one of the country's most prolific creators of political branding. Among the most notable was the aspirational slogan "Soomali heshiis ah dunida naheshiis la ah" (Somalia at peace with itself and with the world). Always more ideal than reality, the phrase now rings hollow at a time when the nation remains deeply fractured internally and relations with regional neighbours have grown increasingly frosty. Similarly, the Simón Bolívar-style moniker "Dal xoreeye" (The Liberator) feels intensely contradicted by reality as significant swathes of the country risk reverting to Al-Shabaab control. Other slogans, such as "Birmade" and "Dan Qaran", have likewise been quietly discarded.


26:10 min read 04 Nov
Issue No. 130
The Elephant on the Summit: Ethiopia’s War Cannot Be Won the Old Way
The Horn Edition

Ethiopia’s leaders are fighting a new war with an old conviction: that military victory can permanently settle the question of who owns the state. But the coalition that encircled Tigray in 2020 has fractured, the regional balance has shifted, and drone capabilities are spreading to the government’s opponents. The battlefield looks familiar, but the strategic conditions are profoundly different. The danger lies in mistaking the temporary capture of territory for the resolution of deep-seated conflict, a ruinous road Ethiopia has travelled before; its towns bear the scars, and its people carry the losses.


9:36 min read 28 Oct
Issue No. 981
The Desperation Conundrum: How HSM Is Unravelling Somalia
The Somali Wire

In social psychology, the term "desperation conundrum" refers to a psychological paradox wherein an acute, extreme, or severe need for an objective inadvertently impedes its attainment. This occurs because an intense sense of urgency frequently drives choices and behaviours that alienate the very outcome that is so desperately sought.


0 min read 23 Oct
Issue No. 980
Somalia’s Volatile Calendar – The October Jinx
The Somali Wire

Somalia’s contemporary political trajectory is profoundly defined by the month of October. Within the Somali collective consciousness, October is not merely another page on the calendar; it is the recurring crucible of political upheaval, tragedy and systemic transformation.


26:19 min read 21 Oct
Issue No. 979
Using Force Against Sheikh Sharif a Bad Idea
The Somali Wire

The Federal Government of Somalia (FGS) has since 10 October been deploying National Intelligence and Security Agency (NISA) forces, specifically the little-known Public Protection Forces (Ilaalada Shacabka / People’s Protection Forces), in Wadajir. This mobilisation is concentrated close to the home of ex-President Sheikh Sharif Sheikh Ahmed – a development widely criticised by many Somalis as provocative. Some interpret the build-up as a prelude, possibly, to some form of armed action against the former president and leader of the opposition Somali Future Council, amid uncorroborated media reports that President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud (HSM) has used Abgaal clan elders to relay an ultimatum demanding the disarmament of Sharif and other opposition figures.


11:59 min read 14 Oct
Issue No. 978
Setbacks on Three Fronts Signal Big Risks for Somalia’s Federal Government
The Somali Wire

It’s been a bruising week for the Somali Federal Government (FGS), headed by President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud (HSM), whose constitutional term of office expired in May this year. Yesterday, forces aligned with the administration of Jubaland peacefully took control of the strategic border town of Beled Haawo in Somalia’s Gedo region – a lucrative customs post for trade and transit with Kenya. Roughly 1,000 Daraawiish paramilitaries loyal to Abdirashid Hassan Janan – a fickle politician who is notorious for changing sides in a volatile region – reportedly deployed across key sites in the town following negotiations with the previous local administration.


9:18 min read 09 Oct
Issue No. 977
The Politics of 'Hiiraan State': The Hawaadle Discontent
The Somali Wire

Plans are intensifying within Hiiraan to establish an autonomous "Hiiraan State." This development reflects deep-seated regional and clan cleavages reasserting themselves in local politics, set against the backdrop of a stalled federal process, a breakdown in talks between President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud (HSM) and the opposition Somalia Future Council (SFC), and an unravelling Somali federation.


23:44 min read 30 Sep
Scroll