Issue No. 750

Published 04 Nov 2024

The Risk of Collapse (Again)

Published on 04 Nov 2024 18:52 min
The Risk of Collapse (Again)

Somalia's delicate post-civil war political contract, theoretically based on decentralisation and clan inclusivity, is under severe strain. The risk of another major unravelling of the Somali political settlement and the state has never been more apparent. While political turmoil continues to roil the country, Villa Somalia remains embarked on a path certain to lead to further discontent and fragmentation at a highly delicate moment. President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's (HSM) re-centralisation, select and dubious constitutional gerrymandering, experimental gambit to fast-track Somalia into representative democracy and direct elections, and blanket term extension for regional presidents have all contributed to a rapid collapse of trust in the central authority and galvanised the country's centrifugal instinct. Now, with Somalia just one month away from a security transition that would place a heavier burden on Somali forces, the potential for further consolidation of Al-Shabaab power remains high.

The last two weeks brought all these negative trends together. Against all sensible advice, HSM cut yet another deal with the presidents of Galmudug, Hirshabelle and South West State (SWS) for unilateral term extensions under the dubious guise of 'one-person, one-vote' (OPOV) elections. Under the terms of HSM's latest agreement with the three regional presidents, the Federal Member State (FMS) leaders have been handed another one-year term extension. In theory, local elections will be conducted in June 2025, and regional presidential polls in September 2025. The new timetable is almost a replica of an earlier one agreed upon by the NCC in May 2023, which has since lapsed, that started the ball rolling on the sweeping rewrite of Chapters 1-4 of the Provisional Constitution. But with the leaders of Darood-majority Puntland and Jubaland opting to stay away from the proceedings, any outcome has been effectively rendered illegitimate. 

The regional presidents are not the only check-and-balance to face co-opting by Villa Somalia. Last week, HSM hosted a rare dinner for members of Somalia's bicameral parliament and opposition leaders in a bid to convince them that holding OPOV elections within the year is feasible. In a speech, the president implored them to postpone their scheduled recess by one month so as to pass the electoral bills on the OPOV modalities. Yet these modalities are also highly contentious and centralising in nature, placing the regional elections under the authority of a federally-appointed committee. Moreover, rushing contradictory legislation through parliament does not change the security realities that it will be impossible to conduct elections in large swathes of south-central Somalia due to the presence of Al-Shabaab.

Prominent opposition leaders have criticised the new agreement between HSM and some regional leaders as both unconstitutional and unworkable. Former President Sheikh Sharif Sheikh Ahmed dismissed it as wishful thinking while accusing the incumbent president of misleading the nation on the feasibility of OPOV, stoking division, and undermining confidence in Somali state-building. These sentiments were also echoed in a joint statement with prominent opposition leader Abdirahman Abdishakur and former PM Hassan Ali Khaire.

Meanwhile, the Mogadishu-Kismaayo schism continues to deepen. In the last 24 hours, two junior ministers from Jubaland resigned from the HSM administration, citing their principled objection to the country's trajectory. On Sunday evening, Jubaland President Ahmed Madoobe called on all Jubaland representatives serving in the federal parliament in Mogadishu to return to Kismaayo for consultations. This, in itself, is unprecedented. The prospect of Madoobe pulling out of an administration led by one of his protégés, PM Hamza Abdi Barre, and ally Hassan Sheikh would have been inconceivable just a few months ago. And to the north, it is clear that the Puntland administration feels vindicated by what is happening in Mogadishu, having withdrawn from the NCC in January 2023. It feels strengthened by the fact that Madoobe and Jubaland are arriving at the same conclusion they have come to-- that HSM is instinctively anti-federalist and seeking to dismantle years of painstaking Somali state-building and incremental democratic change.

Amid the domestic and regional turmoil, the Somali president has travelled to Europe and is scheduled to appear at an investor conference in Frankfurt. HSM usually wields such events to showcase Somalia as a country on a solid path to peace and prosperity. Yet the events last week, including government soldiers clashing over clearances on public land and another shelling of Halane, should surely dent the 'Somalia Rising' narrative beloved by the nationalists and some internationals ensconced in the Halane compound.

For more than a year, the risks inherent in HSM's flawed electoral plan and constitutional review, as well as the destabilising resurgence of the Islamist far-right and Somali nationalists who now form his core support constituency, have been clear. Yet it has taken Somalia to reach the edge of the precipice and the threat of regional war for some in the international community to wake up to the dangerous course Mogadishu has embarked upon. The situation today is also a reflection of the repeated unseized moments by those with influence to steer the administration towards more realistic and viable electoral models.

The route to stability starts with HSM acknowledging reality and changing tack. He will need to return back to the old path of painstaking but necessary Somali clan consensus and contract to rebuild cohesion. To begin with, HSM will need to bring Puntland and Jubaland back to the fold and cease the attempts to undermine his political opponents. But Villa Somalia must also acknowledge that, despite their rhetoric, genuine OPOV that can be considered 'free and fair' across Somalia remains unachievable. For the moment, a system of enhanced democracy is plausible - a hybrid electoral model that has progressive modern features and is also underpinned by Somali clan representation-- but even that will require hard work and acceptance, which is badly amiss. However, to abandon the disliked 4.5 clan system now without a viable and realistically achievable model in the absence of broad national consensus is to put the country on extremely shaky grounds-- to say the least.

The Somali Wire Team 

To continue reading, create a free account or log in.

Gain unlimited access to all our Editorials. Unlock Full Access to Our Expert Editorials — Trusted Insights, Unlimited Reading.

Create your Sahan account Login

Unlock lifetime access to all our Premium editorial content

You may also be interested in

Issue No. 985
The Hiiraan Insurrection – A Crisis Foretold
The Somali Wire

Months of simmering tensions in the Hiiraan region and escalating political rifts with Mogadishu have morphed into a full-blown armed insurrection this week. This development compounds the widening revolt across Somalia's periphery against President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's (HSM) administration, deepening its political isolation.


28:17 min read 18 Nov
Issue No. 983
Hassan Sheikh Runs Out of Road
The Somali Wire

In a landmark ruling last week, five senior judges of Somalia’s Supreme Court declared incumbent President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud’s (HSM) May 2026 term extension unlawful and held that Parliament’s mandate had expired in April 2026, thereby rendering Villa Somalia’s "one-person, one-vote" (OPOV) electoral process illegal and its outcome invalid. Consequently, the judges directed all Somali political parties to agree on a new electoral framework within 30 days and conduct a credible poll within 90 days.


25:51 min read 11 Nov
Issue No. 982
Loo Joojin Maayo – Somalia’s Runaway Train
The Somali Wire

Every political system generates its own distinctive catchphrases, slogans, and metaphors, and Somalia is no exception. Indeed, the administration of President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud (HSM) has proven to be one of the country's most prolific creators of political branding. Among the most notable was the aspirational slogan "Soomali heshiis ah dunida naheshiis la ah" (Somalia at peace with itself and with the world). Always more ideal than reality, the phrase now rings hollow at a time when the nation remains deeply fractured internally and relations with regional neighbours have grown increasingly frosty. Similarly, the Simón Bolívar-style moniker "Dal xoreeye" (The Liberator) feels intensely contradicted by reality as significant swathes of the country risk reverting to Al-Shabaab control. Other slogans, such as "Birmade" and "Dan Qaran", have likewise been quietly discarded.


26:10 min read 04 Nov
Issue No. 130
The Elephant on the Summit: Ethiopia’s War Cannot Be Won the Old Way
The Horn Edition

Ethiopia’s leaders are fighting a new war with an old conviction: that military victory can permanently settle the question of who owns the state. But the coalition that encircled Tigray in 2020 has fractured, the regional balance has shifted, and drone capabilities are spreading to the government’s opponents. The battlefield looks familiar, but the strategic conditions are profoundly different. The danger lies in mistaking the temporary capture of territory for the resolution of deep-seated conflict, a ruinous road Ethiopia has travelled before; its towns bear the scars, and its people carry the losses.


9:36 min read 28 Oct
Issue No. 981
The Desperation Conundrum: How HSM Is Unravelling Somalia
The Somali Wire

In social psychology, the term "desperation conundrum" refers to a psychological paradox wherein an acute, extreme, or severe need for an objective inadvertently impedes its attainment. This occurs because an intense sense of urgency frequently drives choices and behaviours that alienate the very outcome that is so desperately sought.


0 min read 23 Oct
Issue No. 980
Somalia’s Volatile Calendar – The October Jinx
The Somali Wire

Somalia’s contemporary political trajectory is profoundly defined by the month of October. Within the Somali collective consciousness, October is not merely another page on the calendar; it is the recurring crucible of political upheaval, tragedy and systemic transformation.


26:19 min read 21 Oct
Issue No. 979
Using Force Against Sheikh Sharif a Bad Idea
The Somali Wire

The Federal Government of Somalia (FGS) has since 10 October been deploying National Intelligence and Security Agency (NISA) forces, specifically the little-known Public Protection Forces (Ilaalada Shacabka / People’s Protection Forces), in Wadajir. This mobilisation is concentrated close to the home of ex-President Sheikh Sharif Sheikh Ahmed – a development widely criticised by many Somalis as provocative. Some interpret the build-up as a prelude, possibly, to some form of armed action against the former president and leader of the opposition Somali Future Council, amid uncorroborated media reports that President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud (HSM) has used Abgaal clan elders to relay an ultimatum demanding the disarmament of Sharif and other opposition figures.


11:59 min read 14 Oct
Issue No. 978
Setbacks on Three Fronts Signal Big Risks for Somalia’s Federal Government
The Somali Wire

It’s been a bruising week for the Somali Federal Government (FGS), headed by President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud (HSM), whose constitutional term of office expired in May this year. Yesterday, forces aligned with the administration of Jubaland peacefully took control of the strategic border town of Beled Haawo in Somalia’s Gedo region – a lucrative customs post for trade and transit with Kenya. Roughly 1,000 Daraawiish paramilitaries loyal to Abdirashid Hassan Janan – a fickle politician who is notorious for changing sides in a volatile region – reportedly deployed across key sites in the town following negotiations with the previous local administration.


9:18 min read 09 Oct
Issue No. 977
The Politics of 'Hiiraan State': The Hawaadle Discontent
The Somali Wire

Plans are intensifying within Hiiraan to establish an autonomous "Hiiraan State." This development reflects deep-seated regional and clan cleavages reasserting themselves in local politics, set against the backdrop of a stalled federal process, a breakdown in talks between President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud (HSM) and the opposition Somalia Future Council (SFC), and an unravelling Somali federation.


23:44 min read 30 Sep
Scroll