Issue No. 716

Published 09 Aug 2024

Balancing the Scales: Federalism and Resource-Sharing in Somalia

Published on 09 Aug 2024 15:06 min

 Balancing the Scales: Federalism and Resource-Sharing in Somalia
 

Balancing resource collection and distribution is vexing in any federal system. There is often an instinctive push-pull dynamic between the central government and peripheral administrations that agitate for independent and equitable forms of resource distribution. In Somalia today, agreements on collecting and sharing the domestic and international 'rents' remain highly fraught between the federal government and respective Federal Member State (FMS) administrations.
 
While Mogadishu claims to enjoy de jure control over national resources and wields this argument to collect sovereign rents on everything from overflight fees to fishing licenses to signature bonuses on petroleum deals, in reality, it is the FMS administrations that often exercise de facto control over natural resources and revenue collection. More broadly, tax and revenue collection remain highly contentious, with no agreed constitutional or legal framework and the federal government trying to impose a singular, unitary model that it can dispense at will. Since 2012, the attempts to standardise and bring income-generating assets under the federal government's control have run into resistance from FMS administrations. This is perhaps of little surprise when one considers that the deep sea ports of Bosasso and Kismaayo are instrumental in sustaining the incumbent presidents in Puntland and Jubaland, respectively, maintaining their independence from Mogadishu. Notably, one of the major reforms not achieved as part of Somalia's Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) Initiative process was the harmonisation of customs tariffs across Kismaayo, Bosasso, and Mogadishu.
 
Still, last year, some progress was reached on paper between federal and regional ministries in agreeing to implement a number of financial and economic harmonisation reforms. Much of the groundwork was done as part of Somalia's push to complete the HIPC Initiative that forgave the overwhelming majority of the national debt at the end of 2023. The subsequent budget was the country's largest– topping USD 1bn for the first time– almost entirely derived from the international community. The FMS administrations were keen to reap these apparent rewards from debt relief, so it will be interesting to see whether any benefits from the windfall actually trickle down to Somalia’s regions. Moreover, Ministers' promises of increased tax collection are suspect when one considers that the federal government’s inland revenue is almost entirely derived from the municipality of Mogadishu, with Al-Shabaab controlling most of Somalia’s interior, and Puntland – the wealthiest FMS – suspending all cooperation with Villa Somalia.
 
The expected imminent tabling of Chapters 5-9 of the Provisional Constitution for parliamentary review, even if only serving to rubberstamp Villa Somalia's agenda, may throw other elements of resource-sharing back into the spotlight. Chapter 5 contains several key articles regarding Somalia's resources, particularly 50 and 54. The first outlines the principles of federalism, emphasising fair distribution of resources, cooperation, and the equitable sharing of national wealth. Article 54, meanwhile, deals explicitly with allocating powers and resources, stating that fiscal powers and resources shall be negotiated and agreed upon between the Federal Government of Somalia (FGS) and FMSs.
 
There may be little change to the actual wording of these articles, but the incumbent Hassan Sheikh administration has shown its disdain for federalism that permeated through his first term (2012-2017). With Puntland still absent from participating in the constitutional review process, the entire ordeal has been heavily compromised. Attempting to reword or undermine the federal model of resource-sharing – which can motivate Somali politicians more than just about any other issue – without the oldest and most stable FMS will surely prove unimplementable down the line.
 
At the heart of the ongoing Garowe-Mogadishu dispute are their contrasting visions of federalism, with Puntland the more vigorous advocate for a less centralised Somalia. And, again, resource distribution has been wielded by the federal government as a punishment against the Said Abdullahi Deni administration, currently withholding USD millions intended for the Northern FMS. This includes a reported USD 16 million in grants from the Global Partnership for Education designed for education projects in Puntland, which were supposed to be implemented by Save the Children and CARE International. Federal Education Minister Farah Abdulkadir's attempts to deflect criticism onto Puntland at a recent parliamentary hearing were roundly dismissed by several lawmakers.
 
This week also saw a revealing interview with Abdihakim Ainte, a senior climate government official, in The New Humanitarian. Attacking Somalia's aid dependency, humanitarian organisation and lack of development planning, he proposed directly funnelling the money into Mogadishu's accounts as a solution. While Ainte’s critique of aid dependency was largely legitimate, his proposed solution – to channel funds through the FGS instead – was, at best, disingenuous. He entirely neglected to mention that the federal government is incapable of delivering goods or services much beyond Mogadishu and its environs, or the graft that consistently places Somalia at the bottom of Transparency International’s Global Corruption Index.


Ainte did, however, inadvertently sum up one of the principal reasons federalism has never taken root in Somalia– that those who end up the centre are inevitably reluctant to decentralise power and resources. The withholding of money from Puntland hardly engenders other FMS administrations to sign up to release their lifeblood to Mogadishu or implement a unified import tax system when funds are so blatantly manipulated for political reasons. Despite the government's stated commitment to equitable distribution, Jubaland and South West State have also reported receiving inadequate funding for essential services and development projects when compared to Mogadishu.
 
In part, as a response to this, there have been growing instances where donor countries and international organisations have chosen to engage directly with individual FMS administrations and bypass routing money through Mogadishu. This is also a response to the massive corruption undermining project implementation. For example, in Galmudug, the World Bank has directly supported public administration reforms and local governance projects, while in South West State, USAID and the World Bank have provided direct support for education and health projects. The UN has also provided direct technical and financial support to Puntland for governance initiatives, including the preparation and execution of the recent direct local elections. The international community's increasing direct engagement with Somalia's member states suggests a mistrust of the federal government's ability to manage resources transparently or responsibly.
 
Somalia's federal system, designed nearly 20 years ago, was intended to decentralise power and ensure equitable resource distribution among its still-non-existent member states. Returning to the principles of federalism in Chapters 5-9, and where executive power lies in Article 94, should give those in the federal government a moment to pause. The centre and periphery agreeing on resource collection and distribution are fundamental to any competent and comprehensive federal system. More likely, though, if Villa Somalia can manipulate the parliamentary numbers to work in their favour, we will see a repeat of earlier this year, when the first four chapters were rushed through without effective scrutiny. There is a space for both collaborative resource collection in Somalia, currently a minuscule amount, and subsequent distribution, mainly from international partners. However, undermining the groundwork for short-term political wins will make any long-term economic progress far trickier. Finding a compromise and balance over the country's resources that can actually be implemented across Somalia is the finest of tightropes.


by the Somali Wire Team

To continue reading, create a free account or log in.

Gain unlimited access to all our Editorials. Unlock Full Access to Our Expert Editorials — Trusted Insights, Unlimited Reading.

Create your Sahan account Login

Unlock lifetime access to all our Premium editorial content

You may also be interested in

Issue No. 127
Total War in the Horn of Africa
The Horn Edition

'Give Peace a Chance' was the title of a 1969 single written by John Lennon, recorded during his famous honeymoon 'bed-in' with Yoko Ono. Capturing the counterculture sentiments of the time, it was adopted as an anthem of the anti-Vietnam War movement in the following decade. Thirty years later, a provocative inversion of the title-- 'Give War a Chance'-- was adopted in a well-known Foreign Affairs article by Edward Luttwak in 1999, in which he argued that humanitarian interventions or premature negotiations can freeze conflict, resulting in endless, recurring war. Luttwak contended that war has an internal logic, and if allowed to 'run its course', can bring about a more durable peace.


27:16 min read 30 Apr
Issue No. 954
The Malian Mirror
The Somali Wire

A foreign-backed president, a besieged capital city, and a jihadist movement affiliated with Al-Qaeda-- this time not Somalia, but Mali. Late last week, Jama'at Nusrat al-Islam wal-Muslimin (JNIM), the transnational Salafist-jihadist group in Mali, stormed across much of the country's north, as well as entering Bakamo and assassinating the defence minister. The coordinated offensive-- in conjunction with the Tuareg separatist movement, the Azawad Liberation Front (ALF)-- has left the military junta reeling, and forced the withdrawal of their Russian allies from a number of strategic towns.


10:18 min read 29 Apr
Issue No. 329
Washington eyes Asmara
The Ethiopian Cable

Last week, a bombshell Wall Street Journal article revealed that Washington was exploring a reset in relations with Eritrea, with US envoy for Africa Massad Boulos having met privately with senior regime officials in Egypt. Any normalisation of ties now appears to be on ice, with the reaction to Boulos's meetings — facilitated by Egypt — having been met with short shrift. But the episode speaks to broader issues about American foreign policy in the Horn and the accelerating reconfiguration of the Red Sea political order, which will not go away simply because this particular overture may have stalled.


0 min read 28 Apr
Issue No. 953
A Coronation in Mogadishu – How Clans Stormed the Citadel
The Somali Wire

Last weekend, the Murusade, a major sub-clan of the powerful Hawiye clan family, staged one of the largest and most colourful coronations of a clan chief in recent memory in Mogadishu. The caleemasarka (enthronement) of Ugaas Abdirizaq Ugaas Abdullahi Ugaas Haashi, the new Ugaas or sultan of the Murusade, was attended by thousands of delegates from all parts of Somalia. Conducted next to the imposing and magnificent Ottomanesque Ali Jim'ale Mosque, on the Muslim day of rest, Friday, the occasion blended the Islamic, the regal and the customary; a restatement of an ancient tradition very much alive and vibrant.


21:22 min read 27 Apr
Issue No. 952
Fishy Business: IUU Fishing in Somalia
The Somali Wire

With all eyes trained on the Strait of Hormuz blockades and their geopolitical convulsions, discussions and concerns, too, have risen about the perils of other globalised chokepoints, not least the Bab al-Mandab. The threats to the stability of the Bab al-Mandab, the Gulf of Aden, and the Red Sea may not arise principally from the escalatory logic that the US, Iran, and Israel have been locked in, but the threats posed from collapse and contested sovereignty offer little relief. Off Somalia's northern coastline in particular, it is transnational criminal networks — expressed in smuggling, piracy, and, less visibly but no less consequentially, illegal, unreported, and unregulated (IUU) fishing — that define the character of offshore insecurity. It is this last phenomenon that provides the foundation on which much of Somalia's maritime disorder is built, and which remains the most consistently neglected.


21:07 min read 24 Apr
Issue No. 126
Russia in the Horn: Opportunism in an Age of Disorder
The Horn Edition

In the past months, a number of unsettling images and videos have emerged from the Russian frontlines in the Ukraine war. Within the horrors of the grinding "kill zone," where kamikaze drones strafe the sky for any signs of movement, yet another concerning dimension has emerged—the use of African recruits by Moscow in the conflict, often under false pretences. Particularly drawn from Kenya, many reportedly believed they were signing contracts to work as drivers or security guards, only to be shipped to the front lines upon arrival. Such activities are illustrative of several issues, including Russia's relationship with countries in the Horn of Africa, one shaped more by opportunistic realpolitik than genuine partnership.


28:23 min read 23 Apr
Issue No. 951
Federal Overreach in Baidoa Faces Pushback
The Somali Wire

Villa Somalia's triumph in Baidoa may yet turn to ashes. Since the ousting of wary friend-turned-foe, Abdiaziz Laftagareen, in late March, the federal government has ploughed ahead with preparations for state- and district-level elections in South West. Nominally scheduled for next week, President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud has chosen to reward his stalwart parliamentary ally, Aden Madoobe from the Rahanweyne/Hadaamo, with the regional presidency after some vacillation, naming him the sole Justice and Solidarity Party (JSP) candidate


0 min read 22 Apr
Issue No. 328
The TPLF versus the TIA-- again
The Ethiopian Cable

Another showdown over Tigray's political architecture is unfolding, with the future of the Tigray Interim Administration (TIA) once again at stake. For much of this year, fears of renewed war have loomed over Ethiopia's northernmost region, with the federal government mobilising substantial forces to the edges of Tigray.


19:44 min read 21 Apr
Issue No. 950
A City Without Its People
The Somali Wire

In Act III, Scene I of William Shakespeare's tragedy Coriolanus, the tribune Sicinius addresses the gathered representatives and, rejecting the disdain the titular character displays towards plebeians, defends them, stating, "What is the city but the people?" Capturing the struggle between the elite and the masses of ancient Rome, the line has remained politically resonant for centuries--emphasising that a city, democracy, and state rely on the people, not just their leader. Or perhaps, not just its buildings. It is a lesson missed by Villa Somalia, though, with the twilight weeks of President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's term in office — at least, constitutionally — dominated by the government's twin campaigns in the capital: land clearances and the militarisation of Mogadishu.


20:32 min read 20 Apr
Scroll