Issue No. 660

Published 13 Mar 2024

Squaring the circle: A two-party system and proportional representation

Published on 13 Mar 2024 14:12 min

Squaring the circle: A two-party system and proportional representation
 

Parliamentary debates on the Fourth Chapter of the Provisional Constitution began on 11 March. The critical chapter, 'Representation of the People,' covers Somalia's electoral and governance systems, with the published draft incorporating the controversial National Consultative Council (NCC) agreement from May 2023. While the wider process has been dubbed a 'review' of the constitution, the sweeping modifications to this chapter essentially render it entirely new. Nearly 10 months have passed since the NCC agreement, yet much of the content integrated into the Provisional Constitution remains vague and inconsistent. One of the most alarming elements is the contradictions inherent between the proposed 'proportional representation (PR) closed-list system' and the designated 'two parties' that will be allowed to contest future federal elections.
 
A 'proportional' system is supposed to be precisely that– directly and accurately reflecting the vote of the people. PR has been previously touted as a potentially transformative electoral model for Somalia, and a possible alternative to the first-past-the-post (FPTP) model used in the 4.5 clan formula. A closed-list PR model is also supposed to be relatively straightforward to implement and allow for greater representation of marginalised communities. However, the notion of 'proportionality' can be entirely disregarded if only two parties are allowed to compete in future federal and regional presidential elections. While PR is meant to expand choice and representation, prescribing a two-party system does the exact opposite. Multi-party coalitions in countries that use PR, like Germany, would not occur in Somalia; instead, a single party would assume power.
 
Previous attempts by former President Mohamed Abdullahi Farmaajo to introduce PR from 2017 onwards ran into significant political headwinds for reasons that remain relevant today. The proposed 'single constituency' that would elect the president and parliament, rather than multiple smaller districts, was seen as certain to upset the current power distribution among the clans. Politicians from more marginal sub-clans protested that their influence would be diminished as the more influential and populous clans would take their parliamentary seats. If a two-party system is adopted, marginal voices and communities will also likely be squeezed from Somalia's political space. A handful of party bosses would replace the role of traditional elders in elections when picking parliamentary candidates.
 
While a "multi-party political system" is mentioned in the constitution's first four chapters, just two "political organisations" will be allowed to compete in federal elections. The stipulations for these new political parties are briefly outlined, but the language remains open for interpretation. According to the proposed changes, each party must "protect, apply, strengthen and promote the unity of the Republic" as well as support human rights, democratic principles, and "good governance." More ambiguous are the lines that each party "must ensure an inclusive public representation and give special priority to minorities… in membership and leadership." Similar language is used to describe these parties' obligations to the role of women– but gone is the 30% quota. Whether this means that there would be some equivalent quota for fielding candidates remains to be seen.
 
As long as they abide by the new provisions, local council elections will then decide Somalia's two major 'political organisations.' These two new political parties will be allowed to compete in all national polls, including for both chambers of the federal parliament and the presidency. Regional elections will be impacted too; again, only two parties will be allowed to compete for every Federal Member State (FMS) presidency. It is further unclear whether other parties could usurp the two established national organisations at subsequent local elections.
 
This element of the Fourth Chapter is hugely concerning and, if implemented, could have wide-reaching repercussions for the future of Somalia's federal model. It appears that every FMS president will be expected to join these political parties if they want to run in any future regional presidential elections– including possibly the delayed polls scheduled for November 2024. Forcing every FMS president to come under a centralised party office in Mogadishu will surely face significant opposition. It is highly unlikely that the more independent FMS leaders, including Puntland President Said Abdullahi Deni, will simply leave their political futures to others, who could theoretically pick other candidates to run for their seats.
 
Limiting the country to just two electoral choices raises several other issues, not least that it contradicts the principles of a free and fair democracy that Somali politicians like to espouse. It will prevent the organic rise of smaller parties on a national level that could campaign on particular issues, such as the rights of Somalia's vast displaced population. Moreover, without a clear left-right split in Somalia's politics, the two emerging parties would likely be varying forms of Islamist, including one likely centred on President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's ruling Damul Jadiid faction.
 
The Independent Constitutional Review and Implementation Commission (ICRIC), which has the responsibility, along with the Oversight Committee (OC), for converting the Provisional Constitution into a workable document, is seemingly aware that these contradictions between a two-party and PR exist. The ICRIC has laid out a brief rationale beside every change made to the draft of the constitution. Article 50 of Chapter Four, titled 'Electoral System,' reads that the "electoral system of the Federal Republic of Somalia is based on one person one vote and is defined by a law enacted by the Federal Parliament of Somalia." Yet the only comment by ICRIC alongside this change is that a bill will be passed by the federal parliament at an undetermined date to "define the details of a system of representation of the closed list."
 
One of the problems is that the ongoing constitutional 'review' process is essentially kicking the can down the road on several critical issues. Without a clear arbiter of the contradictions within the constitution, it appears likely that another set of ad hoc resolutions will need to be found. It has also become increasingly apparent that no one-person, one-vote (OPOV) polls will occur in any immediate regional or national elections. However, if the 4.5 system is torn up, several indirect negotiated votes will also need to occur, effectively contradicting the newly amended Provisional Constitution.
 
With the parliament soon expected to shut for the remainder of Ramadan and the debates rattling along at breakneck speed, the opportunities for incisive debate and input on Somalia's electoral system have been deeply limited. Still, there will have to be some sort of future reckoning and amendment process to delineate how a two-party system can function alongside PR. Whether this can be resolved by the federal parliament or a constitutional court is yet to be seen, but the willingness to introduce fresh contradiction into Somalia's supreme document is highly alarming. This process could have been a nationwide consultative and collaborative project, not the rushed and opaque process we see today.


By the Somali Wire team

To continue reading, create a free account or log in.

Gain unlimited access to all our Editorials. Unlock Full Access to Our Expert Editorials — Trusted Insights, Unlimited Reading.

Create your Sahan account Login

Unlock lifetime access to all our Premium editorial content

You may also be interested in

Issue No. 127
Total War in the Horn of Africa
The Horn Edition

'Give Peace a Chance' was the title of a 1969 single written by John Lennon, recorded during his famous honeymoon 'bed-in' with Yoko Ono. Capturing the counterculture sentiments of the time, it was adopted as an anthem of the anti-Vietnam War movement in the following decade. Thirty years later, a provocative inversion of the title-- 'Give War a Chance'-- was adopted in a well-known Foreign Affairs article by Edward Luttwak in 1999, in which he argued that humanitarian interventions or premature negotiations can freeze conflict, resulting in endless, recurring war. Luttwak contended that war has an internal logic, and if allowed to 'run its course', can bring about a more durable peace.


27:16 min read 30 Apr
Issue No. 954
The Malian Mirror
The Somali Wire

A foreign-backed president, a besieged capital city, and a jihadist movement affiliated with Al-Qaeda-- this time not Somalia, but Mali. Late last week, Jama'at Nusrat al-Islam wal-Muslimin (JNIM), the transnational Salafist-jihadist group in Mali, stormed across much of the country's north, as well as entering Bakamo and assassinating the defence minister. The coordinated offensive-- in conjunction with the Tuareg separatist movement, the Azawad Liberation Front (ALF)-- has left the military junta reeling, and forced the withdrawal of their Russian allies from a number of strategic towns.


10:18 min read 29 Apr
Issue No. 329
Washington eyes Asmara
The Ethiopian Cable

Last week, a bombshell Wall Street Journal article revealed that Washington was exploring a reset in relations with Eritrea, with US envoy for Africa Massad Boulos having met privately with senior regime officials in Egypt. Any normalisation of ties now appears to be on ice, with the reaction to Boulos's meetings — facilitated by Egypt — having been met with short shrift. But the episode speaks to broader issues about American foreign policy in the Horn and the accelerating reconfiguration of the Red Sea political order, which will not go away simply because this particular overture may have stalled.


0 min read 28 Apr
Issue No. 953
A Coronation in Mogadishu – How Clans Stormed the Citadel
The Somali Wire

Last weekend, the Murusade, a major sub-clan of the powerful Hawiye clan family, staged one of the largest and most colourful coronations of a clan chief in recent memory in Mogadishu. The caleemasarka (enthronement) of Ugaas Abdirizaq Ugaas Abdullahi Ugaas Haashi, the new Ugaas or sultan of the Murusade, was attended by thousands of delegates from all parts of Somalia. Conducted next to the imposing and magnificent Ottomanesque Ali Jim'ale Mosque, on the Muslim day of rest, Friday, the occasion blended the Islamic, the regal and the customary; a restatement of an ancient tradition very much alive and vibrant.


21:22 min read 27 Apr
Issue No. 952
Fishy Business: IUU Fishing in Somalia
The Somali Wire

With all eyes trained on the Strait of Hormuz blockades and their geopolitical convulsions, discussions and concerns, too, have risen about the perils of other globalised chokepoints, not least the Bab al-Mandab. The threats to the stability of the Bab al-Mandab, the Gulf of Aden, and the Red Sea may not arise principally from the escalatory logic that the US, Iran, and Israel have been locked in, but the threats posed from collapse and contested sovereignty offer little relief. Off Somalia's northern coastline in particular, it is transnational criminal networks — expressed in smuggling, piracy, and, less visibly but no less consequentially, illegal, unreported, and unregulated (IUU) fishing — that define the character of offshore insecurity. It is this last phenomenon that provides the foundation on which much of Somalia's maritime disorder is built, and which remains the most consistently neglected.


21:07 min read 24 Apr
Issue No. 126
Russia in the Horn: Opportunism in an Age of Disorder
The Horn Edition

In the past months, a number of unsettling images and videos have emerged from the Russian frontlines in the Ukraine war. Within the horrors of the grinding "kill zone," where kamikaze drones strafe the sky for any signs of movement, yet another concerning dimension has emerged—the use of African recruits by Moscow in the conflict, often under false pretences. Particularly drawn from Kenya, many reportedly believed they were signing contracts to work as drivers or security guards, only to be shipped to the front lines upon arrival. Such activities are illustrative of several issues, including Russia's relationship with countries in the Horn of Africa, one shaped more by opportunistic realpolitik than genuine partnership.


28:23 min read 23 Apr
Issue No. 951
Federal Overreach in Baidoa Faces Pushback
The Somali Wire

Villa Somalia's triumph in Baidoa may yet turn to ashes. Since the ousting of wary friend-turned-foe, Abdiaziz Laftagareen, in late March, the federal government has ploughed ahead with preparations for state- and district-level elections in South West. Nominally scheduled for next week, President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud has chosen to reward his stalwart parliamentary ally, Aden Madoobe from the Rahanweyne/Hadaamo, with the regional presidency after some vacillation, naming him the sole Justice and Solidarity Party (JSP) candidate


0 min read 22 Apr
Issue No. 328
The TPLF versus the TIA-- again
The Ethiopian Cable

Another showdown over Tigray's political architecture is unfolding, with the future of the Tigray Interim Administration (TIA) once again at stake. For much of this year, fears of renewed war have loomed over Ethiopia's northernmost region, with the federal government mobilising substantial forces to the edges of Tigray.


19:44 min read 21 Apr
Issue No. 950
A City Without Its People
The Somali Wire

In Act III, Scene I of William Shakespeare's tragedy Coriolanus, the tribune Sicinius addresses the gathered representatives and, rejecting the disdain the titular character displays towards plebeians, defends them, stating, "What is the city but the people?" Capturing the struggle between the elite and the masses of ancient Rome, the line has remained politically resonant for centuries--emphasising that a city, democracy, and state rely on the people, not just their leader. Or perhaps, not just its buildings. It is a lesson missed by Villa Somalia, though, with the twilight weeks of President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's term in office — at least, constitutionally — dominated by the government's twin campaigns in the capital: land clearances and the militarisation of Mogadishu.


20:32 min read 20 Apr
Scroll