Issue No. 658

Published 08 Mar 2024

No Transparent Constitutional Review Process

Published on 08 Mar 2024 12:50 min

No Transparent Constitutional Review Process

By this time next week, Somalia's federal parliament should be moving into recess, following an unexpected parliamentary extension into Ramadan. Villa Somalia had promised a complete parliamentary review of the first four chapters of Somalia's Provisional Constitution by 15 March, but this seems increasingly unlikely. The review process instead stalled on Chapter 2, with the joint parliamentary session required to review Chapter 3 only reaching the necessary quorum on 6 March.

Even if Somalia's Upper and Lower Houses succeed in reviewing all four initial chapters by mid-March, it is highly unlikely they would have time to vote on any or all of the proposed amendments. And this is a 'big if,' as it has recently been reported that only some 40 Members of Parliament (MPs) showed up to vote over the past two weeks, though some legislation was nonetheless passed. As Ramadan nears, it seems increasingly improbable that a quorum can be reached to complete the review of the first four chapters during this session. 

Analysts are now reporting that at least some of the most controversial of the May 2023 National Consultative Council (NCC) proposals are being integrated into Chapters 1-4 of the Provisional Constitution by the Independent Constitutional Review and Implementation Commission (ICRIC), with Oversight Committee (OC) review and approval. These likely include language pertaining to extensions of Federal Member State presidential elections to November 2024, as well as a one-person, one-vote system. If the contentious NCC proposals are indeed adopted, it would suggest a transition to an OPOV system by the 2026 presidential election. It is highly unlikely that the necessary mechanisms to achieve this would be feasible within that timeframe. Consequently, we could expect a return to an indirect negotiated election, which would in essence contravene the newly amended Constitution.

The first four chapters of the Provisional Constitution currently under review are the Declaration of the Federal Republic of Somalia; Fundamental Rights and Duties of Citizens; Land, Property and Environment; and Representation of the People. From what we have learned, well over 100 proposed amendments are being considered in the first four chapters alone. While some international partners are particularly concerned about the rights of children and women, other controversial sections will surely surface once the revised text is made accessible-- beyond parliament-- to all groups required to be engaged per the 24 January procedures. Questions on how just two parties would be eligible to run in elections, or how precisely the proposed 'closed-list proportional representation' system would operate are still unclear.

Beyond the release and translation of the first four amended chapters of the Provisional Constitution, those involved in the review and approval process should expect to lay eyes on a 'drafting report' that clearly describes the process of making changes to the 2012 document. Members of the current ICRIC and OC are considered the most proficient and collegial group of constitutional experts Somalia has seen to date.

Still, it is widely understood that these crucial committees have not been provided sufficient technical legal assistance to most effectively turn political proposals and outdated provisional sections into clear and understandable constitutional language. The lack of technical assistance in the drafting of the National Consultative Council (NCC) proposals was blatant in their contradictory nature. In fact, we should anticipate the ultimate release of multiple sections of the revised Provisional Constitution that are simply not implementable without subsequent debate, as well as judicial consideration. 

Similar to a dearth of adequate technical support for the review process, there has been insufficient financial and political support for a full set of consultations with non-governmental actors. The 24 January procedures require that academics and civil society, including women, minorities, and representatives from less prominent regions of Somalia, be consulted in preparing the amended Provisional Constitution. Instead, a few hastily arranged meetings with pre-determined participants who were already supportive of the NCC-proposed electoral changes were convened in Mogadishu.

While it is reasonable to hope for a clearly amended Provisional Constitution moving ultimately towards finalisation over the coming months and years, it is not reasonable to expect the first four chapters to be approved over the coming days. There are many questions still to be answered, many processes— and texts-- to be made transparent, and complex procedures to follow to ensure that Somalia's constitutional review process is both legal and constitutional in itself. Rather than clarifying existing questions about the country's foundational text, the current constitutional review process is raising many more.

If public consultations aren't completed, parliamentary debate isn't fully carried out, quorum procedures aren't respected, and amended text is not circulated and carefully considered, this will turn into an illegitimate process. International partners should, therefore, seek to slow the rush, insisting that the law is respected, debate is allowed, and agreed-upon procedures are followed so that an emerging legitimate Constitution is not tarnished for political gain before it has even been created.


By the Somali Wire team

To continue reading, create a free account or log in.

Gain unlimited access to all our Editorials. Unlock Full Access to Our Expert Editorials — Trusted Insights, Unlimited Reading.

Create your Sahan account Login

Unlock lifetime access to all our Premium editorial content

You may also be interested in

Issue No. 123
Another Election and Djibouti's Succession Problem
The Horn Edition

Apathy pervades the Djiboutian population. A week tomorrow, on April 10, the country will head to the polls, with President Ismaïl Omar Guelleh seeking a 6th— essentially uncontested — term in office. With his coronation inevitable, his family's dynastic rule over this rentier city-state will be extended once more. But in a region wracked by armed conflict and geopolitical contestation, the ageing Guelleh's capacity to manage the familial, ethnic, and regional fractures within and without grows ever more complicated. And Djibouti's apparent stability is no product of institutional strength, but rather an increasingly fractious balance of external rents and coercive control-- underpinned by geopolitical relevance.


23:43 min read 02 Apr
Issue No.944
Türkiye's Deepwater Reach in Somalia
The Somali Wire

In the 17th century, the Ottoman polymath Kâtip Çelebi penned 'The Gift to the Great on Naval Campaigns', a great tome that analysed the history of Ottoman naval warfare at a moment when Constantinople sought to reclaim maritime supremacy over European powers.


21:14 min read 01 Apr
Issue No. 325
Dammed If They Do
The Ethiopian Cable

Why have one mega-dam when you can have three more? Details are scarce, but Ethiopia has unveiled plans to build three more dams on the Blue Nile, just a few months after the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) was completed.


14:12 min read 31 Mar
Issue No. 943
Baidoa Falls and Federal Power Prevails
The Somali Wire

Villa Somalia has prevailed in Baidoa. After weeks of ratcheting tensions, South West State President Abdiaziz Laftagareen proved a paper tiger this morning, unable to resist the massed forces backed by Mogadishu. After several hours of fighting, Somali National Army (SNA) forces and allied Rahanweyne militias now control most of Baidoa and, thus, the future of South West. In turn, Laftagareen is believed to have retreated to the protection of the Ethiopian military at Baidoa's airport, with the bilateral forces having avoided the conflict today.


18 min read 30 Mar
Issue No. 942
A Son Sent to Die in Jihad
The Somali Wire

Last October, Al-Shabaab Inqimasin (suicide assault infantry) overran a National Intelligence and Security Agency (NISA) base in Mogadishu, freeing several high-ranking jihadist detainees and destroying substantial quantities of intel. A highly choreographed attack, the Inqimasin had disguised their vehicle in official NISA daub, weaving easily through the heavily guarded checkpoints dotting the capital to reach the Godka Jilicow compound before blowing open the gates with a suicide car bomb. In the months since, Al-Shabaab's prodigious media arm-- Al-Kataib Media Foundation-- has drip-fed images and videos drawn from the Godka Jilicow attack, revelling in their infiltration of Mogadishu as well as the dark history of the prison itself. And in a chilling propaganda video broadcast at Eid al-Fitr last week, it was revealed that among the Inqimasin's number was none other than the son of Al-Shabaab's spokesperson Ali Mohamed Rage, better known as Ali Dheere.


22:20 min read 27 Mar
Issue No. 122
A brief history of Sudan's child soldiers
The Horn Edition

In early 1987, the commander of the Sudanese People's Liberation Army/Movement (SPLA/M), John Garang, is reported to have issued a radio order, instructing his field officers to gather children to be dispatched to Ethiopia for military training. Garang's command conveyed the rebels' institutionalisation of a well-established practice of child soldiering; a dynamic that has been reproduced by virtually every major armed actor in Sudan-- and later South Sudan-- since independence. Today, as war has continued to ravage and metastasise across Sudan, few communities and children have been left untouched by the ruinous violence.


30:05 min read 26 Mar
Issue No. 941
Echoes of the RRA: Identity and Power in South West State
The Somali Wire

The Rahanweyne Resistance Army (RRA) did not emerge from a shir (conference) in October 1995 to defend a government, nor to overthrow it. Rather, the militia —whose name was even explicit in its defence of a unified Digil-Mirifle identity —arose from the ruin of Bay and Bakool in the years prior, and decades of structural inequalities.


21 min read 25 Mar
Issue No. 324
A War Deferred or Avoided?
The Ethiopian Cable

War has been averted in Tigray-- for now. In early February, tens of thousands of Ethiopian federal soldiers and heavy artillery streamed northwards, readying themselves on the edges of the northernmost region for seemingly imminent conflict.


23:53 min read 24 Mar
Issue No. 940
Baidoa or Bust for Hassan Sheikh
The Somali Wire

The battle for South West—and Somalia's political future—continues apace. With the brittle alliance between South West State President Abdiaziz Laftagareen and President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud having broken down spectacularly, the federal government is pouring in arms and forces to oust the Digil-Mirifle leader. Staring down the barrel of the formal opposition holding three Federal Member States and, with it, greater territory, population, and clan, Villa Somalia is looking to exploit intra-Digil-Mirifle grievances—and convince Addis—to keep its monopolistic electoral agenda alive. But this morning, Laftagareen announced a 9-member electoral committee to hastily steer his re-election, bringing the formal bifurcation of the Somali state ever closer.


20:23 min read 23 Mar
Scroll